How Can Lawyers Help Struggling Borrowers With Their Mortgage Loan

November 5th, 2010

Following my previous post, where I propose a decalogue of tips to obtain a response from the bank when it is just not possible to keep repaying, below I have excerpted a sample of a letter of instruction, given to a lawyer, to act on behalf of the troubled borrower when nothing else has worked. The associated fees are not so important (there is absolute freedom in this respect) but it would give a guidance as to what should be expected when having to deal with this scenario and the actions that can be taken.

Letter to Potential Client

Dear Mr Doe

In relation to our services regarding your mortgage loan, our firm can act for you in three distinct stages:

Actions to attempt to reduce the mortgage installment whether by re-mortgaging, conversion of the repayment to interest only, reduction of the interest rate being applied (3.5 % should be the interest payable now) or a combination of all. The acceptance by the bank implies signing a contract with the new conditions and requires that you are present, unless we act for you with a power of attorney.
Actions to attempt to obtain an agreement whereby the debt is to be cancelled against transfer of the property to the bank, if repaying a loan is not possible. The acceptance by the bank implies signing a mortgage deed of transfer of the property and requires that you are present, unless we act for you with a power of attorney.
Actions in a Court of Law should none of the above are attained. In this instance you may need to have a lawyer acting for you if the equity on the property is substantial as you may wish to try to sell before auction (or ensure you get a fair deal) and this requires liaison with Court proceedings. Also, if you reach the auction stage, having a lawyer may help in ensuring that if there are bidders for the property they can get the information for the property promptly, even if it means providing them with access to it (many bidders refrain precisely because they cannot access the property, which is an obvious thing!). Finally, note that it is possible for the bank to foreclose and adjudicate the property, through the Courts, for 50% of the value of the property for mortgage purposes (that generally coincides with the valuation), which could be far less than the debt. This means that if the value of the property is 100.000 the debt is 90.000 Euros, the bank could end up keeping the property for 50.000 Euros, and you would still owe 40.000 Euros. It is therefore recommendable to appoint a lawyer and find a “dummy” bidder (who would be a friend) to force the bank to push up the bid as much as possible. This however would require lodging 30% of the value of the property for mortgage purposes, a deposit that would be reimbursed by the Courts.

Courts can take up to 12 months to finally adjudicate the property to the creditor or a third party so there is some time to act.

If the equity is negligible or negative (the outstanding mortgage loan will need to be increased by an average of 10 per cent for legal fees and arrears) there is no point in incurring in heavy legal fees unless there is an opportunity to sell it, or there is a risk that a substantial portion of the debt will remain unsettled (as explained in point 3). Renting the property during this period will bring in some cash but it is advisable to inform the tenant of the situation, unless it is for short rental.

Our fees to act on your behalf have already taken into account the financial difficulties faced and are as follows:

For Stage 1: 750 Euros plus VAT (inclusive of signing at the Notary office).
For Stage 2: 1400 Euros plus VAT (inclusive of signing at the Notary office
For Stage 1 and 2: 1600 Euros VAT.
For stage 3: will depend on the value of the property (minus whichever amount paid as above).

Although it is not possible to force banks to agree, acting quickly can help your position as bankers sympathise with borrowers who are sincere and upfront in their proposals. We are aware that your current predicament is shared by many property owners and that you may sustain a monetary loss if you eventually lose the property. In addition, it is important that you take some measures to limit or even eliminate completely any bad credit records both in Spain and in your country as well as to try and prevent any further action by the bank.