Search:     Go  
The Spanish Lawyer Online
The Spanish Lawyer Online

Antonio Flores’ Blog

Thoughts about laws and regulations which affect foreigners in Spain
Home > Property > Communities of Owners: what’s the official language of an AGM (Annual General Meeting)?

Communities of Owners: what’s the official language of an AGM (Annual General Meeting)?

July 28th, 2016

ComunidadPropietarios_321431648

This matter was raised in Court on at least four occasions and interesting rulings resolved the matter, albeit in different directions.

In La Manga (Murcia), a Community of owners was made up of 150 owners of which only 2 were Spanish. An AGM was conducted and approved in English, with the benefit of a translator for the 2 Spanish owners.

Not happy with the extensive use of Shakespeare’s language, the two Spaniards challenged the ruling in Court stating that Spanish was the official language of the country and hence, it should have prevailed. The Court of First Instance dismissed the ruling on the basis that a) the governing law on communities of owners had no particular norm on the matter and that b) the Spanish owners had had the benefit of a translator.

The Appeal Court, surprisingly, revoked the prior ruling stating that the Horizontal Property Act came under article 3.1 of the Constitution and, citing national sovereignty, concluded that the language of choice for the AGM should be prima facie Spanish, and thereafter as many translators as required by the different nationalities present at the meeting, at the Community’s expense.

Not content with the outcome, the dispute was escalated to the Supreme Court who overturned the ruling on grounds that the Appeal Court had wrongly understood the application of article 3.1 of the Constitution, which does not apply to juridical agreements conducted privately. The Supreme Court stated that “national sovereignty” has nothing to do with AGMs. Furthermore, it held that as the Horizontal Property Act does not specify the language of meetings, these can be conducted in any [language] so long as translators are available. Clearly, the Supreme Court recognized the multicultural nature of many AGMs along the Spanish Costas and rejected being influenced by notions of antiquated patriotism.

Down south, Malaga Appeal Court ruled that using English language in an AGM had not infringed any rights as the minutes were also in Spanish and at all times, a translator had been fully available.

About Antonio Flores

Antonio Flores is the head lawyer at Lawbird, a Spanish law firm specialised in property and litigation. More on .

Property , , ,

  1. No comments yet.